# Verdict

> Design review as MCP tools: critique, states, journeys, UI copy, PRD assumptions. BYOK or hosted.

- name: com.allthepossibles/verdict
- version: 1.0.0
- connection class: R0 (autonomous)
- trust: 83/100 flags: no-repository
- quality: 89/100 (new)
- owner: not claimed
- descriptor: https://api.protogrid.dev/v1/servers/com.allthepossibles%2Fverdict
- tools: https://api.protogrid.dev/v1/servers/com.allthepossibles%2Fverdict/tools

**An agent can connect right now, no human step.** Remote endpoint, no authentication, reachable on the last probe.

## Connection (mcpServers)

```json
{
  "mcpServers": {
    "verdict": {
      "type": "http",
      "url": "https://verdict.allthepossibles.com/mcp"
    }
  }
}
```


## Trust

- hygiene: 80
- liveness: 100
- freshness: 100
- provenance: 55
- drivers: +dns-namespace +website +reachable +uptime-100% +updated-1d-ago -no-repository
- Derived from observable signals (official registry feed and our own credential-free probes); no code audit performed.

## Quality 89/100 (new)

### protocol: 75 (weight 25)

- warn `protocol.modern`: newest supported version is 2025-06-18; 2026-07-28 not supported, older versions are deprecated until 2027-07-28
- n/a `protocol.stateless`: only applies to 2026-07-28 servers
- pass `protocol.transport`: streamable HTTP
- n/a `protocol.list_ttl`: only applies to 2026-07-28 servers

### authorization: n/a (weight 15)

- n/a `auth.prm`, `auth.as_metadata`, `auth.cimd`: no remote uses OAuth
- n/a `auth.secret_in_url`: no templated URL

### tool hygiene: 100 (weight 30)

- pass `tools.descriptions`: every tool has a description
- pass `tools.description_length`: descriptions are concise
- pass `tools.schemas`: every tool has an object input schema
- pass `tools.annotations`: 6 of 6 tools declare readOnlyHint or destructiveHint
- pass `tools.directory_hints`: every tool declares readOnlyHint, destructiveHint, idempotentHint and openWorldHint
- pass `tools.token_cost`: about 1,002 tokens to load every tool
- pass `tools.api_dump`: tools are not a one-to-one API dump

### stability: n/a (weight 15)

- n/a `stability.changes`, `stability.rug_pull`: tool history recorded for 1 of the 7 days needed

### dependencies: n/a (weight 15)

- n/a `deps.known_vulns`, `deps.mcp_sdk_version`, `deps.resolvable`: no npm or PyPI package

- tools: 6, about 1,002 tokens to load them all
- tool set hash: 106049da48a10c1fb4c69190db99d227
- tools last changed: 2026-10-19T22:42:28.231Z
- badge: [![protogrid quality](https://protogrid.dev/badge/com.allthepossibles/verdict.svg)](https://protogrid.dev/servers/com.allthepossibles/verdict)
- Checks run on what our credential-free, read-only probes observe; tools are never called and no code audit is performed.

### Tool changes

- 2026-10-19 `check_terminology` changed (title, annotations)
- 2026-10-19 `find_assumptions` changed (title, annotations)
- 2026-10-19 `audit_copy` changed (title, annotations)
- 2026-10-19 `map_journey` changed (title, annotations)
- 2026-10-19 `generate_state_matrix` changed (title, annotations)
- 2026-10-19 `critique_experience` changed (title, annotations)

Full history: https://api.protogrid.dev/v1/servers/com.allthepossibles%2Fverdict/changes

## Remotes

- https://verdict.allthepossibles.com/mcp (streamable-http, auth none, reachable true, uptime30d 1)

## Packages

_none_

## Tools (6)

- `audit_copy`: Per-string critique of interface copy: buttons, errors, empty states, confirmations, notifications. Each string comes back with the problem and a fix, or nothing if it already works. Call it before shipping UI strings.
- `check_terminology`: Finds concepts that carry different names across surfaces (UI strings, docs, API reference, support macros) and flags drift. Pass the text from each surface; nothing needs connecting.
- `critique_experience`: Adversarial critique of a design, given as a description or a screenshot URL, with an optional PRD. Returns findings ranked by severity covering hierarchy, density, affordance, composition, copy, and the first-use / 500th-use / zero-data / huge-data / no-permission / irreversible questions. Call it before presenting a design to a human or handing it to engineering.
- `find_assumptions`: Reads a PRD or design brief and extracts the unverified assumptions inside it, ranked by risk, each turned into a research question that could change a decision. Never simulates user answers.
- `generate_state_matrix`: Generates the state space for a feature, form or screen across data, loading, permission, network, account, content, time, concurrency, outside dependencies, money, consistency and people, and lists the gaps most likely to cause real harm. Call it when a feature is described and you want to know what nobody drew.
- `map_journey`: Breaks a user objective into the stages of a real journey and flags entry points and exit paths that have no designed arrival or recovery. Optionally focuses on one user maturity (first use, occasional, habitual, expert). Describes behavior, not screens.